By Charles Layton.
Editor; Blogfinger.net. 2011 Super Bowl.

Christina Aguilera at the Super Bowl
When Christina Aguilera flubbed the lyrics to “The Star Spangled Banner “at this year’s Super Bowl, it revived the perennial argument that America needs a new national anthem.
It won’t happen, of course, but it’s fun to review the issue once in a while.
The most persuasive argument against “The Star Spangled Banner” is that most people can’t handle its range of more than one and a half octaves. At a baseball game or other such function, you’ll see people silently mouthing those unreachable high notes. Or they’ll drop down an octave when they get to “laaaand of the freeeeee…” Or improvise a few lines of alto harmony. (Aguilera switched very awkwardly into falsetto and still didn’t quite nail the high note.)
Another beef you’ll often hear about Spangled Banner is that it’s too militaristic. It’s about bombs.
Any song proposed as an alternative, though, needs to meet three tests: Are the lyrics appropriate? Is it singable? And (my favorite) does it meet what has been called the “Casablanca challenge”?
Alfred Gingold, writing in Slate, once proposed that a national anthem, when sung by patriotic partisans, should be able to silence those arrogant Nazis in Rick’s American Cafe. The French anthem, La Marseillaise, met this test splendidly in the movie. I think Spangled Banner would also succeed in that situation — but only if the people singing it could reach those stirring high notes. If not, it would be pathetic.
So, here are the two most commonly suggested alternatives:
America The Beautiful. Are the lyrics appropriate for a national song? Yes, they are; they declare that the country is beautiful. Is it singable? Yes, it is. Does it pass the Casablanca challenge? Unfortunately not. Waves of grain, fruited plains — that won’t scare very many Nazis.
This Land Is Your Land. Many people champion this song as a national anthem on the grounds that it’s assertive about democracy, expansiveness and inclusiveness on a continental scale. And I agree. It is easily sung, for sure, spanning one note less than an octave. It passes the Casablanca test in my opinion. Furthermore, it’s often sung to guitar and/or banjo accompaniment — what’s more American than that? And it’s structured like an American folk song, with a repeating chorus; it’s designed for group singing.
Here it is, performed by country music artist Lee Greenwood. Sing along if you want to; it’ll make you feel good.















