The last we heard was that there is a long lead time to find housing for tenants prior to demolition.
ELVIS PRESLEY
“Well, since my baby left me
Well, I found a new place to dwell
Well, it’s down at the end of Lonely Street
At Heartbreak Hotel
Where I’ll be, I’ll be so lonely, baby
Well, I’m so lonely
I’ll be so lonely, I could die”
What happens when a property in Ocean Grove gets “tired beyond it’s useful life?” And how about when a property that has housed citizens of Ocean Grove for over 134 years has “outlived its economic usefulness and no longer has any historic or architectural significance?” And what about when it “contributes nothing to the historic district; has no style; is a nightmare to maintain; is broken down with sagging buckling floors and water damage; and when it has significant structural problems?”
Well, all that and more was said last night at a special Historic Preservation Commission demolition hearing regarding 18-20 Surf Avenue, aka the Whitfield Hotel, located at Surf Ave., Beach Ave, Bath Ave., and Lonely Street.
The old 54 room hotel was diagnosed by experts as being “a very large box with no style.” Grovers in the audience could be heard murmuring, “Tear it down.'”
Yet, sitting there and thinking of the building as a home rather than a house, made it seem so sad. But clearly, it is time to sound the death knell. No one would ever buy that building and sink the amount of money into it that would be needed to preserve it for the future.
If the Whitfield were a patient, it would be a candidate for euthanasia, and that is exactly what was in the air last night at the HPC meeting held in the municipal building. Quite a few Grovers were present at the meeting.
The Ocean Grove architect who testified for the owners was Stephen Carlidge, AIA. He and historian Wayne T. Bell were in complete agreement about the insignificance of that property, and, for the most part, the HPC members seemed satisfied that the building is a useless mess.
It was acknowledged that the building is currently safe to use, but its near-future prognosis suggests a bad ending unless a major remodeling were done.
The history of the Whitfield is fascinating. There were only two pieces of actual evidence regarding that history. A Sanborn map of 1889 was reviewed and revealed three wood frame buildings on that 4 lot property. There were two small units—maybe even two tents. The other building was perhaps a two story single family Victorian house. All three structures were certainly residential. There are no old photographs.
Sanborn maps were used to assess real estate until the advent of aerial photography. This one from 1889 was used to evaluate the Hotel Whitfield property.
The next piece of evidence was a postcard from around 1930 when the big box looked as it does today. A history of Ocean Grove in 1939 listed all the hotels in town. The Whitfield was on that list. It offered an “American Plan” for dining, and the proprietor was Charles M. Herman.
Bath Avenue rear view. Historic brackets can be seen near the roof line.
The best explanation of the building’s history is that the three units gradually got larger and eventually “morphed” into one structure, sometime between 1910-1920.
Kevin Chambers, the former President of the Historical Society of Ocean Grove made a surprise appearance at the microphone. He said that he and his colleagues had been watching that property years ago as it became degraded by owners who took out original features such as windows, put in aluminum siding and left no sign of the original architecture. Only a small number of decorative brackets remain. Mr. Chambers said that the building was stripped so much that it “is no longer a contributing structure to the community. ” He recommended demolition as being the best decision for the town.
Mr. Ted Bell said that if we were to grade large historic buildings in Ocean Grove, the Aurora would get the highest rating. That building on Surf Avenue is “one of the best examples of Victorian architecture in New Jersey, and perhaps in America. But the Whitfield would get a zero.”
Janice Green, a resident of Surf Avenue, pleaded with the Commission to approve the demolition.
Mr. Carlidge said that the demo would help the “economic base” of the neighborhood and would allow “something more appropriate on the site.” He then went over the 14 criteria needed to satisfy the demolition ordinance, and this proposal satisfied all 14.
The social aspects of the situation regarding the current occupants were not discussed. That is really not the concern of the HPC, nor are the future plans for the property—at least not at this time.
The only mention of the future was to say that the building must be maintained with all systems working until such time as a demolition were to occur . The fate of the building seems clear now, although an official ruling about the demo cannot be declared until at least 90 days go by (i.e. on Dec 10, 2013) The reason for the 90 days is to give some preservationists the chance to show up and save the Whitfield. Any odds on that happening?
It seems clear as to what the fate of the Whitfield will be, and that will be a correct decision, but it is sort of sad—isn’t it?
Fern wanders the west in her van. Here she spends time with her fellow travelers stopping at a van-park. Paul Goldfinger photograph from the video. 2021. Click photos once to enlarge.
Francis McDormand stars in this bare bones film: Nomadland. Paul Goldfinger photo from the video.
By Paul Goldfinger, MD, Editor. Blogfinger.net This BF review is dated March 7, 2021.
Nomadland is a very basic film, almost monotonous in its tone. It is shot mostly in low light and is permeated by a feeling of sadness. Yet, as you watch the “story” unfold, you learn about how a person, alone, can make a life on the road with hardly any money and no significant support systems.
The people depicted in this film live in small tight vans which sometimes have no heat. She is a member of a subculture of singles who roam from place to place and stay in transient camps where they tap into the way-of-life from which they draw sustenance.
They all form a loose network where they lean on each other, but ultimately they are alone, and many prefer it that way. They spend time at various van-parks, but eventually they move on, perhaps meeting again in an indefinite future.
They are a species of man which has existed for thousands of years–they are nomads.
An example would be the archetypal cowboy of the frontier west—alone against the elements, facing dangers, but managing to survive moving from place to place with his horse and stopping at little towns for whiskey, food and women.
Fern is a middle aged widow who used to work at a factory in Nevada. After her husband died and her workplace closed, she sold everything, bought a modest used van and set out roaming the western states.
She finds a way to survive, picking up seasonal jobs along the way. She makes friends, but they are all temporary and renewable. She has barely enough room in her van to heat up some canned soup.
Fern interacts with people similar to her who have few material possessions but who try and discover the best in others and who share their meager existences. They sit around a fire and sing songs and exchange stories, but it’s difficult to ever feel really happy or satisfied. Sometimes they have barter or trading sales where they put out the simplest objects to provide a measure of variety and treasure.
Nomadland truly has a slim plot, but the pieces fall together to create a world where humans can manage to survive with their humanity intact and somehow to find meager solutions to their hardships. Fern is barely able to maintain her sense of self, but she tries to do that as difficult as it is. This effort stands out in the movie and reminds us how important it is to remain decent.
In one scene she meets a young man and she offers him one of her two sandwiches. She has road friends, and they try to cheer each other with simple gestures and objects such a ribbon in a woman’s hair.
Is it depressing? It is, but you are drawn in and find richness, and somehow you appreciate the elements of what it means to be a person in a very elemental environment.
I was fascinated by this film, having been a fan of Francis McDormand ever since I saw her in Fargo. And the themes appeal to me viscerally as it must do for most who see it.
Congratulations to Chloé Zhao, the brilliant film maker who wrote and directed the picture. McDormand is one of the producers, and she is married to one of the Coen brothers–a duo of off-beat film makers well known in Hollywood.
So far, having recently opened, the film is winning all sorts of awards including Best Picture at the Golden Globes. This is appropriate because this wonderful movie is profound and worthy of attention. Nomadland taps into the basic desire of people to understand and help each other, whereas the usual movie bill of fare seeks out violence, crime, sex, science fiction, horror, and pain.
This film is timely in our society where we now tend to be more alienated from each other for a variety of reasons and maybe we forget to be kind and attentive to others. A simple message.
I would show this film to a teen-ager. (Oh, yes, also an adult.)
On April 25, 2021, Nomadland won Best Picture at the Oscars, and Francis McDormand won Best Actress (her third Oscar.) The films director Chloé Zhao was Best Director
Maurice Sendak is considered to be the most important children’s book author in the 20th century. Among his books are “Where the Wild Things Are” (1963) and the more recent “Bumble-Ardy.” He also was a designer who worked on many operas and ballets. Here is a quote where he mentions a fan letter from a child:
“A little boy sent me a charming card with a little drawing on it. I loved it. I answer all my children’s letters – sometimes very hastily – but this one I lingered over. I sent him a card and I drew a picture of a Wild Thing on it. I wrote, ‘Dear Jim: I loved your card.’
Then I got a letter back from his mother and she said: ‘Jim loved your card so much he ate it.’ That to me was one of the highest compliments I’ve ever received. He didn’t care that it was an original Maurice Sendak drawing or anything. He saw it, he loved it, he ate it.”
Sendak was gay and he lived with his partner for 50 years. He also was an atheist and he often talked about death. He said that his friends who were “believers” had a less difficult time than he did with that subject. Below is a link to four NPR interviews with Terry Gross of “Fresh Air.”
I heard the last interview where he talks about being old. I found it moving.
He said that he was “a happy old man,” but he cried a lot because his friends have died. “They leave me,” he said. Sendak was an atheist, but he was sure that he would meet his deceased brother later. In discussing his life now, he said that he couldn’t walk much due to illness, but he used his time to read books and to listen to music. His favorite author was Emily Dickinson, and he loved the music of Mozart. He said that there were four “young people” whom he mentored that lived with him, so he was not alone.
It seems he liked to express himself in triplets. Regarding death, he said, “I’m ready, I’m ready, I’m ready.” And regarding his advice for those who get close to the end, he said, “Live your life, live your life, live your life.”
Maurice Sendak died of a stroke in 2012 at his home in Connecticut at age 83.
The Great Auditorium of Ocean Grove. Getting ready to perform Felix Mendelssohn’s oratorio “Elijah,” conducted by Jason Tramm. August 28, 2016. The musicians are from the Adelphi Chamber Orchestra. Paul Goldfinger photo. Click to enlarge.
By Paul Goldfinger, Editor @Blogfinger.net. 2016 post.
Kudos to the Ocean Grove Camp Meeting Association for making such remarkable events possible in our town.
Note: Felix Mendelssohn (1809-1847) was born into a prominent German Jewish family, but he was baptized as a Lutheran at age 7. However he remained intrigued by his Jewish heritage.
He became a famous composer when he was in his teens. His biblical oratorio Elijah was inspired by the “Old Testament “regarding Jewish prophets .
Elijah was first performed in England (1846).
Mendelssohn died young (age 38)
STEPHEN DOUGHTY Elijah Part 2. “He, watching over Israel, slumbers not.”
This quote rings true regarding recent events in Israel 2023-2026.
By Paul Goldfinger, Editor @Blogfinger (reposted from 11/29/13)
At Wegmans this morning they were already playing Christmas music. Ironically, they call today “Black Friday”–an odd name for a day that should still be basking in the glow of a happy, happy, merry, merry holiday. An employee that I barely know breezed by and said, “Happy Hanukkah.” I didn’t have time to respond, but I thought, why is she wishing me happy anything?— I don’t really know her. I was already a bit numb from so many people in stores and elsewhere saying, “Happy Thanksgiving.” What’s the point? No amount of good wishes would have any impact on the happiness of my Thanksgiving. And then you have to say “Happy Thanksgiving” back, even though I don’t care about their Thanksgiving. What a drag.
When I was in practice, patients would come in and wish me a “Happy Hanukkah.” So I would wish them a “Merry Christmas,” but these greetings always struck me as awkward. For one thing, what makes them think I’m Jewish? I never told them. Maybe I’m a Moroccan Muslim. I would prefer that they wish me a “Merry Christmas” so that I can fit right in. Then I won’t have to answer questions like, “Is it the fourth or fifth night now?” I seldom know exactly what night it is. Besides, I know they think that Hanukkah is the Jewish Christmas, and I wish I could explain that it is not even close. In my house, when I was a kid, we said a blessing, lit the candles and ate. That was it. And just one present, if I was lucky.
So I went up to the café in Wegmans and sat down to have coffee and a bagel and fiddle around with my iPad. I’m wearing earphones, so I didn’t hear the man come up to me. When I sensed his presence, I looked up and there is a gentleman with whom I sometimes chat at Wegmans. He said that he finds all these merry, merry, happy, happy greetings to be a bit disturbing, because so many people are suffering in the world. He mentioned the Central African Republic where, he said, “genocide” was occurring and also Syria, a place where he spent two years in the past. There they are having death, destruction and a huge refugee problem.
I suggested to him that perhaps Americans are a bit delusional because they don’t know about such places. I never heard of the Central African Republic, so he told me that it used to be a French colony. I always learn stuff at Wegmans. Today I found out that the mashed potatoes are in the dairy department. Go figure!
OK, I know, you all think I’m a curmudgeon, or something else. But we all have our pet peeves. Do you have any pet peeves as it pertains to the happy, happy, merry, merry “holiday season?”
And that’s another darn thing: Say “Merry Christmas” and not “Happy Holiday.” We’re all big boys; even big girls are big boys these days. Americans can handle the possibility of being insulted. Let’s all jettison some piece of political correctness this year. Let’s lighten up this happy, happy, merry, merry season and wish everybody a new greeting. Try something unexpected like, “Ain’t that somethin’?”
And if you see me, wish me a “Merry Christmas.” You’ll find me wandering around the Wegmans lot looking for my bloody car.
THE DIMMER TWINS (“True Blue Aussie Christmas album”)
Articles about parking never grow old on Blogfinger. They tap into the fabric of life in the Grove, and they bring the residential community to the surface for a gasp of fresh ocean air:
Summer, 2017— Modern OG history:
This photo is at Delaware Avenue, just south of Main Avenue. Ironically, there is a funeral home to the right. This street here is very narrow, as are many OG streets. It’s a sunny Saturday in August, and there is gridlock. About 60 seconds before this photo was taken that parking spot was vacated. The prior occupant pulled out of the space very slowly.
30 seconds after that, this vehicle showed up. There was room for parking, but parallel parking in a place like that always feels as if you would hit the car on the other side. You have to have faith in the Lord that you will not do so, and almost always you don’t. This driver must have been sweating this experience. Behind his car is another car waiting.
But why should parking be a frightening expe rience and why do we allow our town to overflow with cars—many more than there are spaces?
NJ.com June 2016: The Neptune mayor Kevin McMillan* was interviewed about OG parking. “We have to take a look at the proposals that do what’s best for the greater good,” McMillan said.
“Bull!!” says Blogfinger.
This is double talk for “we are not going to seriously look at the OGHOA permit parking proposal.” This also is fake news because he doesn’t tell us what “greater good” means. He certainly isn’t giving the residents any advantage.
Parking should not be an absolute democracy. Permit parking works in many other towns which recognize that their residents are special and need assistance. That is the greater good! The objections mentioned by the CMA earlier this week (Aug. 2017 ) are bogus.
In that 2016 NJ.com interview, McMillan said, “There’s no easy solution to the parking issue, and the best way to address it is to let the political process play out.”
Is he serious?? We cannot trust the “political process” in Neptune. Ask them what happened to the revised HPC guidelines——MIA.
And he said, “We’re not going to run away from the problem.”
More gobbledygook! Look what happened over the ensuing year—-nothing but poppycock. The Neptune government specializes in poppycock and they should hang a banner to that effect in front of the Mother Ship.
And now, 2017, Mayor Brantley tells the Coaster (but not the citizens of OG) that permit parking is dead.
Consider Belmar: In 2015 they closed down the entire town when the number of cars exceeded the number of spaces during a seafood festival. But the official Belmar stance on parking, as stated by their mayor, is that they place the interests of their residents first.
Their online site says, “Belmar’s leadership and citizenry always understood that lack of parking is a serious problem here and that increases in the availability of parking must accompany any increased development.”
Do you think the Neptune leadership ever had this thought in mind when it approved condos without parking? I think it is a law which the Neptunites usually ignore.
*In 2026 Kevin McMillan is the Neptune Mayor again after the Neptune Dem party previously had thrown him out over politics even though he was a popular Committeeman.
Paul Goldfinger Editor @Blogfinger.net
MARLENE DIETRICH. She sings this to the Neptune Committee on behalf of OG residents: