
Nov.15, 2026. Sunday night. Nagel’s Apothecary just opened for dinner this week. Not sure about the hours. Closed Monday and Tuesday. Main Avenue in Ocean Grove, NJ, USA. America the Beautiful. Paul Goldfinger photograph. Click once to enlarge.
Sunday, 11/15/26:
By Paul Goldfinger, MD, Editor, Blogfinger.net. 11/15/2026
Blogfinger reporters came to Nagle’s this cold Sunday night. The restaurant has made many happy by opening for dinner this week.
It was glowing in the dark tonight. The scene took on a warm mood due to the gentle lighting inside and out. Diners and staff could be seen inside.
The new dinner menu was so inviting; the product of marvelous planning, drawing on wonderful dishes from another era, and there was a special enticing sub-menu called the “Blue Plate Specials” which really caught my attention at $19.95.
We went in and we were welcomed by the staff. The decor had not been changed from before. It had been empty for years, but it opened for breakfast and lunch this past summer, and we are told that business was very good.
For years visitors would stop at Nagle’s and peer inside. And many fans believed they would re-open.
Blogfinger reporter Stephen Goldfinger went over earlier and he said, “Just went to the new ‘open for dinner’ Nagle’s: BEAUTIFUL: Cozy and warm with lovely lighting and music playing inside and out, Louis Prima, now as people arrived for dinner; open till 9 pm Thursday through Sunday; and the “Blue Plate specials were special indeed.”
“Blue Plate Specials” Each dish has a name. (see menu below) such as Friday: “Chop Night Fever” which is grilled pork chops. Click to enlarge.
Eileen and I had been here twice recently for lunch. We ordered their fish and chips which are excellent . Nagle’s cuisine is amazing: fresh, cooked just right, and a delight to savor. The staff was alert and friendly. The kitchen team came out with a smile to greet us.
Inside the decor was the same as when Len Steen ran Nagle’s years ago.
Sitting near the front window was a couple (below) who seemed to be dressed for the occasion. They looked like they might have been guests from the 1930’s SS Morro Castle which rode the waves in this part of the Jersey Shore and which crashed on the Asbury Beach in 1934.
Morro Castle link: Click on the bold letters:
2013: The wreck of the Morro Castle: survivors show up at the Zombie Walk.
But no, this was their usual Sunday garb. They were happily chowing down on the roast turkey open face dinner. They said that their food was excellent.

The diners looked like they were perhaps part of the cast from “The Three Penny Opera.” Actually the young lady said that she was a “singer.”

Hours: Closed Monday and Tuesday. Not sure about dinner hours. fThe decor was left the same as years ago.

The menu is full of happy surprises. Click once to enlarge. They didn’t have a menu for me to take to my studio, so click once and you will be able to see this amazing gourmet array of down-home dinners. The new owner also owns a highly regarded seafood restaurant in Red Bank, so it is evident that management here is first rate and experienced.
For years, visitors would stop at Nagle’s and pier into the windows, saying how “sad” it was that it had not been reopened. It reminds me of when Moonstruck was on Main Avenue in the Grove, and visitors from out of town would line up to have dinner. This Nagle’s will be like that.
The music playing with a soft volume was wonderful originating in the 30’s to the 60’s. Here is a Louis Prima sample: Click on the song title:
“When you’re smiling, the whole world smiles with you….” Louis Prima



Blogfinger.net has published many articles about Nagles over the years. You can search our archives to see them. PG