Eileen’s Holiday Pot Roast:
Prepare 1-2 days before serving
Preheat oven 350 degrees
5-6 pound brisket
freshly ground black pepper
paprika
5 tablespoons vegetable oil
4 cooking onions, diced
4 carrots, peeled, cut in ¼” rings
4 stalks celery with leaves, ¼” slices
1 package (8-10 oz) fresh cremini or white mushrooms, thinly sliced
5 small cans of whole white potatoes (drained of the liquid)
5 cloves garlic, minced
2 8 oz jars beef gravy
1 cup red wine
1 box low sodium beef or chicken broth
½ cup marinara sauce
Rub paprika and black pepper on both sides of the brisket (approximately 2 tablespoons of paprika & 1 tablespoon black pepper.)
Heat a large oven proof pan (with cover) on the stove. When pan is hot place brisket in pan and sear until meat turns brown. Turn meat over and sear on the other side. Remove brisket from pan and set aside.
Add oil to the pan and heat medium low. Add onions, carrots, and celery. Sauté on medium low heat for 15 minutes. Next add garlic, 1 jar beef gravy, red wine, box of broth, and marinara sauce. Stir the liquids with the vegetables and add the seared brisket to the pan. Place the cover on the pan and put it in the oven for 3 hours. Half way through the cooking time, turn the meat over and continue cooking with lid on pot.
After the 3 hours remove the pan from the oven and allow it to cool. Place meat and gravy in a closed container and store in the refrigerator until the morning of the day you plan to serve the meat. Remove congealed fat and take brisket out of container (scrape gravy off the meat). Slice the brisket in ¼” slices on the diagonal, against the grain of the meat. It is very important that you slice against the grain or the meat will be tough and stringy.
Place the meat in the original pot. Add the gravy, all the potatoes, mushrooms, and 1 jar beef gravy. Place cover on the pot and place in the oven for 2 hours. I serve the brisket right from the pot it was cooked in. Serves 8
—————————————————————————————————————————
By Paul Goldfinger, M.D., Editor, Blogfinger.net. Ocean Grove, New Jersey
The Jewish New Year 2023. (Hebrew calendar 5783) begins on the evening of September 15, 2023. There are a few appropriate greetings for the new year. One that is widely used is “L’Shanah tovah” which translates to “Happy New Year.”
A taste of Jewish history: It’s now 5783 (the New Year) by the Hebrew calendar, and Rosh Hashanah is upon us. The Jewish New Year is a serious religious event, but, like so many of our holidays, food is a big deal, especially traditional recipes. There are a lot of moving parts, but if Eileen leaves out anything she hears about it.
We eat apples dipped in honey for a sweet new year. Pomegranates have a similar purpose. (Although the Chinese like this too.) We have round (goodness without end) egg breads (challah)–often with raisins.
Some of our foods are so good that they show up at multiple holidays. For example there’s chicken soup with matzoh balls and/or noodles. Then there is sweet Kosher wine and, the piéce de résistance—pot roast. (using a particular cut: brisket.)
Of course Jews were scattered all over the world for thousands of years, so there are variations in the foods. If you are in the north east, brisket is usually used, but if you head to other parts of the country, the pot roast is made with different cuts of meat.
Many Jews that one might meet in New Jersey and New York are from families that escaped from eastern Europe during waves of immigration during the late 1800’s to early 1900’s.* So they brought pot roast with them. On the other hand the Sephardic Jews in Deal might have couscous, leeks, pumpkin and fish with the head still attached.
My family, like most others, wanted to be Americanized as soon as possible. And that included customs, dress and language. But the foods were never forgotten. They spoke Yiddish at home because of the grand parents, but they always spoke English elsewhere.
*Another wave of Jewish emigration occurred in the 1930’s as Hitler took over Germany. Those who escaped landed anywhere they might avoid the “final solution.” So some wound up in places like China and India, but other safe places included America, Canada, Palestine, Mexico, England and others. When I was a kid my parents liked to go to Coney Island in Brooklyn, NY. There, on the beach, I noticed many Jewish Holocaust survivors with numbers tattooed on their arms.
My relatives referred to America as the “Golden Land”
Here is a Yiddish song by the Barry Sisters. It’s called: “In Meina Oigen Bistie Shain” (In my eyes you look beautiful.)
From an album called To Life: Songs of Chanukkah and other Jewish Celebrations.
And here is Mandy Patinkin who made an album of songs sung in Yiddish, and in this song he celebrates America–not the old world, but the new…..
RRS:
I buy brisket from Wegmans. It cooks up tasty & tender.
Eileen
That is some fine looking brisket! I am inspired to buy some prime quality brisket from Costco and try this recipe.
Thank You for the History and Recipe, Eileen and Paul!
Wegmans has a large selection of brisket now in the meat department, and you can get one as small as 2 lbs. Their brisket is very good.
A nice farewell remark during the holidays: “Don’t let your pot roast!”
I made Eileen’s Holiday Pot Roast over the weekend and it was fantastic. I think making it in advance is key; my usual pot roast recipe from my Mother benefits by sitting for a day, too.
I am ready to say that Eileen’s is even better; it has more elements that give it a deeper flavor. Nice slicing job for the photo, too!
That pot roast looks so yummy. My mouth is watering.
I am putting Brisket on my shopping list!!
Thank you for the recipe.
Jimmy Fallon started his show last night saying, “It’s Rosh Hashanah folks, so all our Jewish writers are off today…..well, that’s the show, good night.”
So our people brought humor with them. They needed it for much of those 5,778 years.